From 75204d613465355b80787cf83ea74adba55ca532 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Eric Rakestraw Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 14:26:50 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Set root identities and expand bundled profile plan --- docs/roadmap/bundled-openrouter.md | 101 ++++++++++++++++++----------- 1 file changed, 62 insertions(+), 39 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/roadmap/bundled-openrouter.md b/docs/roadmap/bundled-openrouter.md index d87a4b7..3d9dfeb 100644 --- a/docs/roadmap/bundled-openrouter.md +++ b/docs/roadmap/bundled-openrouter.md @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Proposed; no implementation changes yet. -Ship a small OpenRouter configuration collection with PromptKit so consumers +Ship a small OpenRouter configuration bundle with PromptKit so consumers can begin using named profiles without installing a separate catalog. Include the backend definition those profiles require. Keep separately maintained operator collections fully supported through the existing configuration path. @@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ that release; no further upstream enhancement is required for this feature. ### Ordinary Embedded Configuration -Embed a small YAML collection in PromptKit and load it through the existing +Embed a small YAML bundle in PromptKit and load it through the existing ConfigKit adapter. Place it in its own lowest-priority underlay, before every caller underlay and the main input. Preserve the existing order and grouping of caller inputs. @@ -56,9 +56,23 @@ listing and inspection APIs. Source explanations should identify embedded configuration meaningfully. There is no need for a parallel built-in catalog API or special provenance model. +### Root Resource Layout + +Use root entries for both the backend and all built-in profiles. The backend +ID is `openrouter`; each bundled profile references `backend: openrouter` and +is selected using its unqualified ID. No built-in `openrouter` collection is +created, so an externally supplied collection can expose names such as +`openrouter/gpt-sol-latest` alongside the root `gpt-sol-latest` profile. + +Built-ins at the root and external libraries under `collections` is a +convention, not an enforced distinction. Applications may supply root entries, +override built-ins, and organize external configuration using either form. +Root names favor convenient selection; their backend remains explicit in the +definition and inspection even though it is absent from the profile ID. + ### OpenRouter Backend -Include a backend with OpenRouter's API base endpoint, +Include the root `openrouter` backend with OpenRouter's API base endpoint, `https://openrouter.ai/api/v1`, and the conventional environment-variable name `OPENROUTER_API_KEY`. Store the name only; no credential value belongs in the bundle. Reuse the existing OpenAI-compatible client and credential resolution. @@ -70,18 +84,29 @@ diagnostics or select an inference smoke-test profile. ### Small Profile Set -The proposed initial set contains these three model selections: +The initial set contains twelve root profiles: -| Proposed profile ID | OpenRouter model value | Purpose | -| --- | --- | --- | -| `openrouter/gpt-sol-latest` | `~openai/gpt-sol-latest` | Follow the current GPT Sol family model. | -| `openrouter/auto` | `openrouter/auto` | Delegate model selection to OpenRouter's auto router. | -| `openrouter/free` | `openrouter/free` | Select OpenRouter's free-model router. | +| Profile ID | Intended model selection | +| --- | --- | +| `gpt-astra-latest` | OpenAI GPT Astra latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `gpt-sol-latest` | OpenAI GPT Sol latest-family alias (`~openai/gpt-sol-latest`). | +| `gpt-terra-latest` | OpenAI GPT Terra latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `gpt-luna-latest` | OpenAI GPT Luna latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `claude-fable-latest` | Anthropic Claude Fable latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `claude-opus-latest` | Anthropic Claude Opus latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `claude-sonnet-latest` | Anthropic Claude Sonnet latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `claude-haiku-latest` | Anthropic Claude Haiku latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `gemini-pro-latest` | Google Gemini Pro latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `gemini-flash-latest` | Google Gemini Flash latest-family alias through OpenRouter. | +| `auto` | OpenRouter auto router (`openrouter/auto`). | +| `free` | OpenRouter free-model router (`openrouter/free`). | -These names distinguish PromptKit resource IDs from provider model values: -the tilde and slash in a provider model slug remain part of that value. -Additional latest-family aliases can be selected before implementation or added -later when useful; completeness across vendors is not a launch requirement. +These profile IDs are selected. Confirm the exact provider `model` slugs for +all family aliases during implementation rather than deriving them mechanically +from profile IDs. If a requested alias is unavailable, surface that mismatch +instead of silently substituting a pinned model or dropping the profile. +The tilde and slash in a provider model slug remain part of that value; they +do not change the root placement of the PromptKit profile. Each profile should primarily specify its backend and model. Avoid baking in temperature, reasoning, token-budget, timeout, or capability assumptions merely @@ -121,8 +146,8 @@ does not identify or pin the concrete model selected upstream. ## Implementation Work -1. Resolve the identity layout and diagnostic-metadata decisions below. Confirm - the initial profile list and current provider endpoint/model values. +1. Resolve the diagnostic-metadata decision below. Verify the provider endpoint + and exact model values for the twelve selected root profiles. 2. Add the embedded YAML backend and profiles, and integrate their dedicated underlay with engine construction. Add the disable option using the existing facade option pattern. Apply the ordinary load/normalize/validate lifecycle. @@ -147,31 +172,29 @@ needed solely to distribute this data. ## Open Decisions -### 1. Backend Identity And Collection Layout +### Smoke-Test Metadata In The Bundled Backend -**Recommendation:** Put profiles in the `openrouter` collection with the local -IDs shown above, and put the backend in that collection as local ID `default`. -Profiles would reference `openrouter/default`. This keeps the bundle together, -avoids an ambiguous doubled provider name, and supports normal collection -inspection. Applications can still replace those exact IDs. +**Recommendation:** Include `smoke_tests.authentication.kind: openrouter_key` +using the existing adapter's backend-relative `/key` endpoint. Leave a separate +reachability endpoint and inference `default_profile` unspecified. The adapter +already exists, so this is a small configuration addition that makes explicit +API-key diagnostics useful out of the box without choosing an inference model. +OpenRouter documents the authenticated +[current-key endpoint](https://openrouter.ai/docs/api/api-reference/api-keys/get-current-api-key). +Its acceptance of a key is evidence about that endpoint, not a guarantee that +an arbitrary inference request will succeed. -**Alternative:** Use a root backend ID `openrouter` with namespaced profiles. -This is concise and may align better with existing operator catalogs. Its -drawback is splitting the bundle between root and collection resources, and -making a common root backend name the shared override target. Before choosing, -compare maintained OpenRouter catalog conventions; the layout should minimize -consumer confusion rather than establish a new naming restriction. +This revises the initial recommendation to omit diagnostic metadata: given the +existing adapter and the bundle's convenience purpose, the added utility seems +worth maintaining the small declaration. The decision remains open pending +maintainer agreement. -### 2. Smoke-Test Metadata In The Bundled Backend +**Alternative:** Include only the backend endpoint and credential-variable name. +This keeps the shipped configuration smaller and leaves diagnostic declarations +entirely with the consumer, but applications wanting authentication diagnostics +must configure the existing adapter themselves. Ordinary inference is unaffected. -**Recommendation:** Include only the endpoint and credential-variable name in -the initial backend. Existing diagnostic behavior remains available, and the -feature stays focused on configuration convenience without choosing a diagnostic -inference model or expanding the maintained provider-specific configuration. - -**Alternative:** Also provide the existing OpenRouter authentication diagnostic -configuration, after verifying its endpoint and behavior, while leaving the -inference smoke-test profile unselected. This makes the bundle more useful for -explicit preflight calls with little data, but adds another upstream convention -to maintain and test. Neither option implies automatic diagnostics during -construction or execution. +Either approach uses existing diagnostic APIs and execution rules. Neither +implies automatic diagnostics during construction or execution. Selecting a +built-in inference smoke-test default would be a separate choice; this proposal +leaves callers able to select a profile explicitly without prescribing one.